Ranked #4 by U.S. News & World Report, the Michigan Ross BBA Program is one of the best undergraduate business program in the world. Explore what makes our inclusive community of learners so unique.
At Michigan Ross, you gain more than just a first-class business education. Our collaborative, supportive, inclusive community enriches your experience, and sets you up with a lifetime network of friends across the globe.
The work of Michigan Ross faculty influences the world’s largest companies and global economies. Every day we’re creating real-world solutions for the most pressing challenges in our world.
Opening a new, dedicated location in downtown Los Angeles provides greater access to a world-class business education for students and professionals on the West Coast.
Complex Firm Structure Can Hurt Stock in Alliances
May 3, 2018
By Maxim Sytch
Image
Maxim Sytch
Matrix companies such as Procter and Gamble, Eli Lilly, General Electric or PepsiCo are more likely to enter into complex alliances with other companies because their very structure gives managers more confidence to collaborate in challenging situations.
Yet, a new study by Maxim Sytch, associate professor of management and organizations at the University of Michigan Ross School of Business, and colleagues finds that the stock market often penalizes companies for such collaborations because they are thought to have diluted strength by juggling complexity both inside and outside.
Sytch and co-authors Franz Wohlgezogen of the University of Melbourne and Edward Zajac of Northwestern University examined the effect of a firm's internal structure on its engagement in alliances with other companies and stock market reaction to the formation of those partnerships. The study will appear in an upcoming issue of the journal Organization Science.
A matrix structure is designed with multiple links across the company's customer, functional, geographic and product groups. You live in a matrix organization if you have more than one boss, such as when you report to both a geography leader and a product leader. Account manager positions and cross-functional teams are all elements of the matrix design, which has become more prevalent in recent years.
"Our tests revealed an intriguing pattern of results," Sytch said. "Matrix organizations are more likely to enter into alliances that include partners from different industries and incorporate various functions in the alliance, such as R&D, manufacturing, or marketing.
"Such alliances are particularly complex to manage: They engender severe coordination demands, knowledge sharing challenges, and conflicts of competing interests. Yet, the stock market largely penalizes matrix organizations for embracing such complex interorganizational collaborations."
Managers of matrix firms were less daunted than nonmatrix firms by entering into complex alliances. This is because the anticipated governance and relational challenges in those alliances largely reflect their daily managerial challenges inside matrix organizations.
"Yet, the matrix firms incur the double-complexity discount for entering into such alliances, especially when there is an anticipation of high coordination costs both internally, within a matrix, and externally, across multiple alliance functions," Sytch said.
"The negative investor response makes visible the practical concerns that exist in the market about the optimality of matrix firms' resource allocation choices. Matrix managers' confidence that matrix structures offer behavioral benefits for managing these partnerships effectively is not reflected in the expected returns by the market."
Maxim Sytch is the Michael R. and Mary Kay Hallman Fellow and an associate professor of management and organizations at Michigan Ross.
Historically, what roles have public policy and corporate regulation played in shaping business practice? From their earliest iterations, corporations were really creations of the monarch or the state, usually to spread financial risk and to accomplish some social good, like exploration and trade...
The Fragmentation of the Mainstream Media The mainstream media, or legacy media, used to consist of just a few news networks. Audiences could tune in to one of their limited choices or elect not to watch the news at all. Professor Ryan discusses how today, the number of people regularly tuning in to...
Page’s research focuses on diversity, institutions, and collective intelligence. He has written five books and more than one hundred articles in management, economics, political science, philosophy, statistics, psychology, and sociology. Page’s primary focus is theoretical, writing models that...